Blankets
David Casseres
casseres at apple.com
Thu Jun 5 20:26:43 CDT 1997
Matthew Weiner sez
>I don't approve of outright nonsense and lying being passed off as mere
>distortions and embellishments. Nor of the guts of the song being passed
>off as "some details" along the way, now that they've been found baldly
>inaccurate.
...and a lot of other stuff.
I was going to stay out of this but I really do have to point out that
what you have is some evidence that in one place, at one time, a couple
of Army types apparently gave a couple of infected blankets to some
Indians. To try to pass this off as evidence that no Indians anywhere,
at any time, were ever given quantities of infected blankets in exchange
for land is grossly irresponsible.
Your use of the words "baldly inaccurate" is just plain bullshit. All
you're really saying is, "if I can't find a written record of it, not
only did it never happen but any poetic assertion of it is outright
nonsense and lying." Rilly, Matthew.
Cheers,
David
More information about the Pynchon-l
mailing list