Hitler's Pope

Hartwin Gebhardt Hartwin.Gebhardt at eqos.com
Fri Oct 1 05:56:40 CDT 1999


Tom Hickey:
> RULE:
> When someone belongs to a group different from your own and 
> holds beliefs
> contradictory to your own then criticizing them is an act of 
> intolerance.
> Especially, god help you, if the issue is religion.
> 
> I don't see why we need to modify that rule in any way.  Right?

I disagree. Criticizing or challenging another's group identity, whether by
painting a black dung madonna or in conversation, is perfectly fine,
provided the power relations are (more or less) between equals. Otherwise
its an act of terrorism. The word tolerance does not feature - it is merely
a liberal buzzword used to legitimize the hegemony of the Western middle
class world view.

hag



More information about the Pynchon-l mailing list