Three best novels of the 1990s

Richard Romeo richardromeo at hotmail.com
Thu Sep 9 10:55:09 CDT 1999


>
>Richard Romeo sez:
>
> > 1. Infinite Jest
>
>boring, overlong crap - not half the imagination of even a TRP short story;
>there ain't no people in it, but then, I didn't manage to finish it, so
>maybe I shouldn't talk
---------------------------
Though I somewhat disagree, I do admit DFW still is a one book wonder--If 
Brief Interviews is what we can expect from the guy, ughh...how many writers 
of today show some sort of growth from book to book--not many. Broom was 
downright lousy, short stories are hit and miss.
>
>
> > 2. Underworld
>
>an overlong, blown up short story - entertaining in part, but nowhere near
>as good as, say, White Noise, which is a kind of low-brow version of
>Pynchon's worst novel, COL49
----------------------
There's so much beauty in Underworld--DD's crowning achievement, a nice 
summary of all his concerns. Maybe it resonates more w/ this kid from NYC.

> > 3.  Mason & Dixon
>
>well now - here we have something else entirely; there is more imagination,
>intelligence and simply good writing (not to mention sheer _work_) in a 
>page
>of M&D than in the other two put together
>
---------------
no argument, there. good to have you back HAG.

p.s. apologies to chris for last night--too much crap happening.  have a 
great trip!

Rich

______________________________________________________
Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com



More information about the Pynchon-l mailing list