Is it OK to be anachronistic?
jbor
jbor at bigpond.com
Fri Mar 16 01:34:34 CST 2001
I think we're pretty much in agreement here, though I still don't think that
that 1710 in the 'Luddite' essay is a typo.
As with the web page, I think there is more than a touch of ambivalence in
Pynchon's essay, as when he refers to "those who, like C. P. Snow, have
thought that in 'Luddite' they have discovered a way to call those with whom
they disagree both politically reactionary and anti-capitalist at the same
time" (para. 6), and then the observation a couple of paragraphs later:
But it's important to remember that the target even of the original
assault of l779, like many machines of the Industrial Revolution, was
not a new piece of technology. The stocking-frame had been around since
1589, when, according to the folklore, it was invented by the Rev.
William Lee, out of pure meanness.
Pynchon casts doubt on the stereotype of Ned Ludd as a "technophobic crazy",
and, in demurring in this way, I don't believe that he would have much
sympathy for Sale's antics -- let alone those of the Unabomber! -- whatever
the virtues of their respective polemics.
Pynchon's position on the issue is close to that expressed in the on-line
essay I think. He writes: "Ned Lud's anger was not directed at the machines,
not exactly." It's the social, human element of the revolt that he is most
interested in.
http://www.themodernword.com/pynchon/pynchon_essays_luddite.html
http://www.fastlink.com.au/subscrib/hit/smash.htm
best
----------
>From: Eric Rosenbloom <ericr at sadlier.com>
>
> Kirkpatrick Sale's book makes it quite clear that it was not the
> technology but the social and economic changes that the Luddites rose up
> against. They smashed the machines when they were no longer theirs.
> Sale's antics represent an application of what he has taken from his
> study of the Luddites, but his book is not colored by it (except in the
> cover hype). In the book, he takes a balanced view, concluding that to
> follow the example of the Luddites is to question new technology as to
> its effects on our lives: Is it taking away as much (or more, or
> something more valuable) than what it gives?
More information about the Pynchon-l
mailing list