Not answering Doug
jbor
jbor at bigpond.com
Wed Oct 17 02:55:43 CDT 2001
MalignD at aol.com wrote:
> And further: the reference to Susan Sontag is worthless and deceitful in
> attempting to prove the point Millison's trying to make.
Yes, there is absolutely no comparison to be made. Susan Sontag has
credibility, deservedly, even though her outburst in the _New Yorker_ was
probably misguided (defending and, despite her protests, eulogising the
hijackers' "courage", no matter how right she might have been on the point
of pedantry she made, was not a wise thing to do at that moment in time, was
bound to be misinterpreted, and she should have expected the backlash. In
fact, to be now publishing a celebrity-style interview on how surprised she
is that her tirade was received as it was is somewhat disingenuous, if not
distasteful.)
quail at libyrinth.com wrote:
> You are a fanatic, Doug, there is no arguing with you, you cannot see any
> middle ground, you browbeat everyone around you, and every single thing that
> happens in this war -- every single thing -- you will just plug into your
> system of preconceived notions, finding in it only confirmation of your own
> unassailable beliefs. I no longer argue with you because I think you will
> listen, I argue with you just because I don't feel I can let your bullshit
> stand.
Yes, refuting the propaganda and misinformation is a worthwhile undertaking,
even though responding to Doug and his lies per se is pointless, as you say.
best
More information about the Pynchon-l
mailing list