Chapter 45: Body & Soul
Terrance
lycidas2 at earthlink.net
Thu Apr 11 07:55:46 CDT 2002
The notion that a man is a soul contained in a body is a false idea that
comes from Plato, who viewed the body as the prison of the soul. We
occasionally
speak of the body in this way (2 Cor. 5:1-4), but this language is not
to be pressed.
The twentieth-century philosopher Gilbert Ryle was wrong when he said
Christians view man as "a ghost in a machine." It would have been more
accurate to say
man is a ghost and a machine.
This makes it clear that expressions of pop culture that imply men can
become angels, such as the songs "Johnny Angel" and "Teen Angel" or the
movie
"It's a Wonderful Life," are misleading on this point, whatever their
other
merits may be.
-Catholic Encyclopedia
Like Carl Barrington of "The Secret Integration", the more
V. functions as an abstract entity, the more she becomes
inanimate and non-human. The processes are co-extensive.
V.'s transformations (identity changes) are directly related
to the development of the major themes in the novel. These
major themes can be grouped under the term "enfetishment."
Enfetishment, is an ironic process because it invests the
inanimate with human characteristics and inanimates human
subtleties, first by divesting human characteristics through
reification and then reinvests them with pseudo-human
characteristics, turning them into fetishes in the process.
They become artificial objects posing as humans, a poor
substitute for humanity, yet fully acceptable in the
decadent world or in Fausto's terms, a world "moving towards
non-humanity." This non-humanity is not, as so many have
argued, simply Pynchon's Borgs or Terminators,
human/machines, humans with plastic parts. The process is
not mechanical and the humans are not machines, but are
humans in a world that no longer recognizes or in is the process of
losing
their humanity.
In his essay, "Is it OK to be a Luddite," Pynchon defends
science fiction, the luddite genre, the gothic, and in the
course of his defense, explains how his own fiction is
constructed and what his concerns are. His concern is not
machines, but humans. In V., Benny Profane has an imaginary
conversation with SHROUD about Elmira's junkyards and
Hitler's Auschwitz: "Remember, Profane, how it is on Route
14, south, outside Elmira, New York? You walk
and see the
setting sun on a junkpile. Acres of old cars. If I could
die, that's what my graveyard would look like."
A few paragraphs after Benny's conversation with Shroud,
Esther has a conversation with Schoemaker: "You want to
change me into something I'm not," she argues. "In return he
could only argue a kind of ***Platonism*** at her." "It was her
soul, he loved." "her soul would be there on the outside,
radiant, unutterably beautiful."
" 'Twas his own Hubris,--the old mad Philosopher story, we
all know, meddl'd where he shouldn't have, till laws of the
unforeseen engaged," M&D.373
"if Angels be the next higher being from Man, perhaps the
Duck had 'morphos'd into some Anatine Equivalent, acting as
my Guardian,--purely as an Angel might
" M&D.379
THE BLUE ANGEL
Allen Ginsberg, Dream, Patterson, Mid-1950
Marlene Dietrich is singing a lament
For mechanical love.
She leans against a mortarboard tree
On a plateau by the seashore.
She's a life sized toy,
The doll of eternity:
Her hair is shaped like an abstract hat
Made out of white steel.
Her face is powdered, whitewashed and
Immobile like a robot.
Jutting out of her temple, by an eye,
Is a little white key.
She gazes through dull blue pupils
Set in the whites of her eyes.
She closes them and the key
Turns by itself.
She opens her eyes, and they're blank
Like a statues in a museum.
Her machine begins to move, the key turns
Again, her eyes change, she sings
--you'd think I would have thought a plan
to end the inner grind,
but not till I have found a man
to occupy my mind.
More information about the Pynchon-l
mailing list