Dietary Fibre

[Malignd]

You must admit, Carvill, your "logic" is a little hard
to follow.  First you said:

<<I would argue that you don't think Vineland is very
good because you don't appreciate it. That's what
'appreciate' means in this context.>>

Don’t want to put words in your trap, but you seem to
be saying that I’m merely offering a tautology.  That
doesn’t follow quite, but I think that’s your point. 

Now you say:

<<I merely suggested that the reason MalignD doesn't
think it's any good is because he doesn't appreciate
it, rather than the other way round.>>

--which suggests to me that you believe a tautology
has direction, that "doesn’t appreciate = doesn’t
think it’s any good," is different logically from
"doesn’t think it’s any good = doesn’t appreciate."

Of course, I may be misrepresenting some subtle warp
in your reasoning, but one does one's best mining
intent through the poncey starchiness of your style. 



__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Search - Find what you’re looking for faster
http://search.yahoo.com