Gunter Grass Admits to Serving in Hitler's Waffen SS

[jd]

I agree RE: the cutoff... but it was already a long film and as a
stand alone product has a good ending...

On 8/14/06, Peter E. Zelz <pzelz at earthlink.net> wrote:
>         The Tin Drum is my favorite, but Dog Years and Cat and Mouse aren't far
> behind.  The Flounder is right up there, too.  And, ditto, if the guy
> has/had a problem in dealing with a particular aspect of his past (and
> which of us hasn't?) it should be no reflection on his reputation as a
> writer or on his comments regarding his feelings about the period.  Imagine
> the weight the bugger's been carrying around all these years.
>         I enjoyed Tin Drum, The Movie but was sorta frustrated that it cut off
> about two-thirds of the way through the novel.  I particularly enjoyed the
> bits in the book about working in a cemetery (always having had a
> particular appreciation for bone yards) and the nun's finger.
>         On a totally self indulgent note:  Any of you folks out there in Pynchon-l
> land have any suggestions on how I might get the man to autograph my copy
> of The Tin Drum?  That book, and its author, have particular resonance for
> me.  My Dad was born a couple years before Grass, but on this side of the
> ocean to immigrant parents.  And, my Zelz ancestors lived in Danzig and, I
> fancy, crossed paths with the author's ancestors in their regular comings
> and goings.  Responses to this last bit would probably best be handled
> off-list.
>
> Cheers,
> z
>
>
>
> > [Original Message]
> > From: jd <wescac at gmail.com>
> > To: David Meury <dmeury at yahoo.com>
> > Cc: <pynchon-l at waste.org>
> > Date: 8/14/2006 17:16:58
> > Subject: Re: Gunter Grass Admits to Serving in Hitler's Waffen SS
> >
> > The movie version of The Tin Drum is one of my favorite book to movie
> > adaptations...  I don't think that his reputation as a writer can be
> > denied due to his service in the SS, it's either good writing or it's
> > not... I've only read The Tin Drum, but I'll say that that is good
> > writing (and certainly not pro-Nazi).  I think that it is easy to
> > understand why he would be inclined to hide such things - if he hadn't
> > said anything, would we not remain ignorant of the fact?  I don't
> > think self-admission can really require the destruction of
> > reputation...  though Otto, you do make a god point re: "conscious of
> > a nation"... but on the other hand, having seen both sides, he might
> > be wiser on certain subjects.
> >
> > I mean heck, the Pope was in the Hitler Youth.  If Grass had admitted
> > this years ago, should he have been denied his voice even if it
> > contained wisdom?  Should it be now?  I don't think so...
> >
> > On 8/14/06, David Meury <dmeury at yahoo.com> wrote:
> > > Why that Schwanzlutscher!
> > >
> > > (Actually, I'm just trying out my new word for the day.)
> > >
> > > __________________________________________________
> > > Do You Yahoo!?
> > > Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
> > > http://mail.yahoo.com
> > >
>
>
>