ATD SPOILER p. 95
Jasper Fidget
jasper.fidget at gmail.com
Wed Nov 29 11:30:23 CST 2006
I completely agree. The wiki is more lecture than conversation, lacking
a decent means to question or discuss, only to correct and un-correct.
The worst thing that can happen is when someone starts adding
questionable interpretive conclusions like Doug's page 95 entry. (That
one wasn't even worth discussing.) I anticipate the wiki turning into a
junkyard full of people's half-baked opinions and Kinbote-esque
commentary (i.e. worse than useless).
On Wed, 2006-11-29 at 08:56 -0800, Ande wrote:
> Why discussion is better than the wiki--which already has "supposition"
> unmoderated by exposure to other perspectives...I grew up blowing things
> up for fun, (and playing with model rocket kits, too) and I read this
> section the same way Scott did, which isn't to say that the interest in
> anarchists isn't political or poignant given 9/11 and the War on
> Terror...looking forward to the group read---and would suggest that the
> wiki be used for "references"....just my 2cents.
>
> Ande
>
More information about the Pynchon-l
mailing list