A question for UK listers
pynchonoid
pynchonoid at yahoo.com
Mon Oct 16 11:23:26 CDT 2006
> Middle class people live in working class
> neighborhoods??
I guess it's the other way around here in parts of the
SF Bay area, where somebody who was able to buy a
house back in the '50s or 60s, when they were clearly
middle or lower-middle class or blue-collar, now finds
herself living in a house worth a million bucks -
"house rich, cash poor" we say around here. Lots of
couples who were just barely able to scrape together a
downpayment and qualify for a mortgage back in the
'70s and '80s in the same situation, too, although I'd
put most of them middle-middle to upper-middle income
group. I think the median price for a single-family
house in the greater SF Bay Area now is over $500,000
and while the market may have cooled a bit in recent
months, it's hard to tell in some place, a house down
the street got 10 bids from potential buyers recently,
and it was no bargain.
It can lead to some funny situations - Italian
scooter-riding gen-x hipsters complaining about their
old SUV and pickup truck-driving neighbors or their
redneck kids for a variety of mutually unintelligible
reasons.
----Not so much
> in my experience on the U.S. West Coast--I applaud
> David Gentle in his
> quest to get this right--it is so important for a
> character to read
> right--may I suggest Black Swan Green--the father in
> this story would be
> late 70s and the protagonist a little young---but
> the milieu--the subtle
> and not so subtle differences between working class
> and middle class,
> between "new" and old...or perhaps a suggestion is
> the Flashman
> example--find a character with an established
> background in an existing
> story and "age" your character forward to include
> him in your novel....
>
> A.
>
>
> Paul Mackin wrote:
>
> >
> > On Oct 16, 2006, at 3:14 AM, Mike Weaver wrote:
> >
> >> To add to Paul's comments:
> >> David Gentle is correct to ask what class you
> have in mind Dave,
> >> though I think he's a tad mechanical in his
> description of class
> >> differences. Remember economic and cultural class
> differences are
> >> not the same thing. Plenty of people come from
> and are, culturally,
> >> of one class while their economic situation and
> outlook is of another.
> >> To be realistic you would need to decide what
> situation this
> >> character was born into - class origins, the
> economic fortunes of
> >> his parents throughout his childhood - rising,
> falling or stable -
> >> Then there is where in the UK he grew up - I'd
> say there are big
> >> regional differences in working class culture,
> less in middle class
> >> and less again in upper class. However the local
> dominance of
> >> particular class cultures are a variant cross
> current acting on the
> >> regional differences.
> >>
> >
> > In the U.S. the idea of "class" or other ways of
> ranking economic
> > status seems to apply mostly to neighborhoods.
> >
> > The newspapers will speak of "working class
> suburbs" "blue collar
> > subdivisions" "areas of modest homes" "prosperous
> neighborhoods"
> > "leafy neighborhoods West of the Park" etc. etc.
> >
> > There don't seem to be any "middle class"
> neighborhoods.
> >
> > "Middle class" as applied to people seems to be
> very broadly defined--
> > not on welfare but unable to pay Harvard level
> tuition for their kids.
> >
> > Middle class people mostly live in working class
> neighborhoods I
> > rather imagine.
> >
> >
> >
> >
>
>
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com
More information about the Pynchon-l
mailing list