NP - Beatles Remasters

[John Carvill]

I just cracked today, and ordered the mono box.

> The mono version clearly makes better use of effects and other mix-related
> options. There's something about the SP mono mix as opposed to the speaking
> about the mono mixes in a more generic fashion. It's the one mono mix that
> really pops out of the set.
>

I agree, the mono is the best version. But, for example, there are
some interesting sounds on 'Lovely Rita' that can only be heard
(properly) on the stereo version.

> Certainly true of the Magical Mystery Tour remaster. And the Stereo White
> Album is generally more highly regarded on the Hoffman list than the mono
> version. Haven't heard that yet, only part of the mono mix, which is quite
> fine, thank you.
>

I think there's a consensus building that the White Album is also one
of the best stereo remasters.

> And yet, it's the basslines and drum parts that really pop out of the new
> cds. There is a consistent elevation of the bottom two octaves in these
> remasters compared to the 87 mixes. There's also a spike around 10k, where
> there's lots of overtones for the drum kit. This is really noticeable on MMT
> and Abbey Road. Try "Baby You're a Rich Man" and "Come Together" and hear
> the difference.

It's true that one of the most immediately noticeable changes is more
bass. But there are also enhanced mid ranges and sharper vocals. An
overall sprucing up of the sound. Compare the muddy obscurity of the
old Past masters verson of Ballad of John & Yoko to the new one, the
remaster is far clearer.


> And yet the one p-lister who actually responded [as opposed to simply
> flinging pot-shots 'n monkey spew] happens to be a hard-core
> Beatle-audiophile/Hoffmanite as well. Figures.

Yehp.

> By the way, viz the Hoffman list—the winner appears to be the stereo
> "Beatles For Sale." That seems like it's everybody's favorite among the new
> remasters.
>

Thing with that forium is, there's just too much to wade through. I
look forward to someone doing a thorough album by album review,
pointing out differences and enhancements.

Haven't heard Beatles for Sale yet, will have to wait until my mono box arrives.