TRP's 20 worst sentences
Paul Mackin
mackin.paul at verizon.net
Sun Sep 20 09:58:13 CDT 2009
Keith wrote:
> The confusion in the wording of those sentences was indeed discussed
> in typical obsessive P-list fashion. I have no problem at all with the
> point I think TRP was making in that section. It matches my biases
> precisely. But the awkwardness and confusion of the wording of those
> sentences is actually quite typical of Pynchon's non-fiction writing.
> Most of us agree with him, and know what he is trying to say, so we
> lose our critical perspective on how awkwardly he writes in these
> instances. It has nothing to do with using verbs wrongly. A visit to
> the archives will illustrate the matter just fine. Perhaps I should
> not be surprised that you resort to "and you know that" in your
> argument, but I am. Good Lord.
>
> On Sep 19, 2009, at 9:21 PM, Otto wrote:
>
> That's not true, Keith, and you know that.
>
> We've discussed the "content", the "politics" in those four sentences,
> but never the grammar. I can't find verbs used wrongly.
>
>
>
Pynchon seemed to be trying to outdo Joyce.
"His (Stephen's) mind was not exactly what you would expect to call
wandering but a bit unsteady and on his expressed desire for some
beverage to drink Mr Bloom, in view of the hour it was and there being
no pumps of Vatry water available for their ablutions, let alone
drinking purposes, hit upon an expedient by suggesting, off the reel,
the propriety of the cabman's shelter, as it was called, hardly a
stone's throw away near Butt Bridge, where they might hit upon some
drinkables in the shape of a milk and soda or a mineral."
Ulysses, p. 613
More information about the Pynchon-l
mailing list