Where did the expertise for "Doktor Faustus" come from?

[Heikki Raudaskoski]

Adorno's adversary Lukács - it is always a treat to follow
a battle of dueling Marxists - wrote the famous essay "Franz
Kafka oder Thomas Mann?" It comes as no big surprise that
for GL, a champion of realism, the latter won hands down.

Adornos modernist darlings included Kafka, Schönberg and
Beckett whose authentic negativity resists commodification.
One is tempted to surmise that "Doktor Faustus" is the one
work by Mann that fulfilled Adorno's stern requirements,
while everything else by TM would play it to the hands of
culture industry with its false consolations.


Heikki

On Thu, 22 Sep 2011, Kai Frederik Lorentzen wrote:

>
> On 21.09.2011 20:15, Matthew Cissell wrote:
>
> > I remember reading Dr Faustus and thinking that Mann had this amazing wealth of knowledge, but then someone pointed out that what he really did well was using material (12 tone and Nietzchean thought and biography) in a way that made you think he knew every hing about modern music and philosophy. Of course Mann was no expert on Schönberg or ...
>
> True enough (though they often had drinks and dinner together in Pacific
> Palisades), but Thomas Mann had the best expert on modern music and
> philosophy one can think of: Theodor W. Adorno, who also makes an
> appearance in the novel as the intellectual incarnation of the Devil
> with his specs and the affected way of talking. At the time Mann was
> writing "Doktor Faustus", Adorno had his most creative
> phase. Wrote the "Philosophy of Modern Music" and "Minima Moralia" (for
> both books Thomas Mann, in
> his gratitude, helped to find Publishing Houses) plus, with Horkheimer,
> the "Dialektic of Enlightenment". Actually Adorno did not only help re
> the music but also on certain aspects of the text. Erika Mann, the
> daughter who hated Adorno, wasn't fond of that and when Thoman Mann
> published "Die Entstehung des Doktor Faustus" (about: The Making of
> Doktor Faustus) she did everything to kick out the most enthusiastic
> passages  about Adorno's great help. There are, as you can see when you
> read this book, still more than enough. To get the full picture do also
> see Mann's diaries and letters!
> And here especially --- Theodor W. Adorno/Thomas Mann: Briefwechsel 1943
> - 1955. Ffm 2002.
>
> On 12/30/45 Thomas Mann wrote to Adorno:
>
> "Es ist merkwürdig: mein Verhältnis zur Musik hat einigen Ruf, ich habe
> mich immer auf das
> literarische Musizieren verstanden, mich halb und halb als Musiker
> gefühlt, die musikalische
> Gewebe-Technik auf den Roman übertragen, und noch kürzlich, zum
> Beispiel, hat Ernst Toch
> in einem Glückwunsch mir 'musikalische Initiiertheit' ausdrücklich und
> nachdrücklich bescheinigt.
> Aber um einen Musiker-Roman zu schreiben, der zuweilen sogar den Ehrgeiz
> andeutet, unter
> anderem, gleichzeitig mit anderem, zum Roman der Musik zu werden ---
> dazu gehört mehr als
> 'Initiiertheit', nämlich /Studiertheit/, die mir ganz einfach abgeht."
>
> Thomas Mann's  knowledge of Nietzsche, however, was profound to the
> highest degree. Tommy
> wrote over the decades several long essays on Crazy Fritz and and
> they're all still solid gold. Actually
> Nietzsche, together with Schopenhauer and Wagner, functioned as Mann's
> theoretical "Dreigestirn"
> (Betrachtungen eines Unpolitischen, p. 97; about:
> Three-Star-Constellation), which he - though very
> critical of Wagner in later years - basically made use of his whole
> artistic life.
>
>
>
>