Re: GR translation: but it’s never discussed except in a general way

[Mike Weaver]

Gotta disagree Joseph. It's the kabbalists's study not the kabbalist 
which is mentioned and the study knows no more magic than the warehouse 
exhibits stoicism.

cheers Mike

On 24/11/2025 17:11, J Tracy wrote:
> I don’t think “who’s supposed to know magic” refers to the bulb. First  it’s in a different sentence ( Others…) and there it makes most sense within the commas surrounding the kabbalist and makes fine sense as a  description of the Kabbalist. It too is a bulb in the Kabbalist’s study.  So there are 3 bulbs that show the generality that light bulbs can be among the tales of the immortals.
>
> You are right about the second instance where it clearly refers to the bulb as  facing the arctic whiteness . P even compares that bulb’s stoicism  to other more southerly bulbs.  It would be dumb to compare a warehouse to other more southerly bulbs.
>> On Nov 24, 2025, at 10:46 AM, Mike Jing <gravitys.rainbow.cn at gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>> V650.1-7, P663.4-10   Byron soon enough becomes a Permanent Old-Timer.
>> Others can recognize his immortality on sight, but it’s never discussed
>> except in a general way, when folklore comes flickering in from other parts
>> of the Grid, tales of the Immortals, one in a kabbalist’s study in Lyons
>> who’s supposed to know magic, another in Norway outside a warehouse facing
>> arctic whiteness with a stoicism more southerly bulbs begin strobing
>> faintly just at the thought of.
>>
>> My understanding of this part is that Byron's immortality is never
>> discussed except when tales of other Immortals come in, and even then it's
>> only discussed in a general way, is that correct?
> I agree
>> Secondly, the clause "who’s supposed to know magic" refers to the
>> lightbulb, right? The published translation treated it as if it's about
>> the kabbalist, which doesn't make sense grammatically.
>>
>> Thirdly, the phrase "facing arctic whiteness with a stoicism . . ." is a
>> whole, and its subject is the other light bulb. The published translation
>> thinks the phrase "facing arctic whiteness" modifies "warehouse", which
>> seems obviously wrong.
>> --
>> Pynchon-L: https://waste.org/mailman/listinfo/pynchon-l
>
>
> --
> Pynchon-L: https://waste.org/mailman/listinfo/pynchon-l