Blankets
David Casseres
casseres at apple.com
Fri Jun 6 14:41:02 CDT 1997
Matthew Weiner sez
>And I am not doing that whatsoever. Sheesh. Meanwhile, the song remains
>baldly inaccurate, historywise. Deal with it, eh? Scrambling to find
>*somewhere* a positive spin *somehow* on its historical contents is not
>going to work.
Listen, you nasty little fucker, the song is neither corroborated nor
contradicted by history, so how the hell can it be "baldly inaccurate,
historywise"? History does not say anything at all about the song.
>>Your use of the words "baldly inaccurate" is
>
> on the money. The guts of the song are indeed baldly inaccurate, as I
>showed with point by point enumeration of its disconnection from reality.
You showed nothing but a lack of written documentation, and some scanty
documentation of what might well have been a completely different
incident.
>You may bother to note that most of the historical errors had nothing to
>do with the blankets before lying your head off about what I did or did
>not "try to pass off".
There are no "historical errors" to note. Do not call me a liar; you did
indeed try to pass off a lack of evidence as contradictory evidence, and
you are still doing so.
>>All you're really saying is, "if I can't find a written record of it, not
>>only did it never happen but any poetic assertion of it is outright
>>nonsense and lying."
>
>Liar. I said exactly what I said.
Asshole. You said exactly what you said.
Cheers,
David
More information about the Pynchon-l
mailing list