camera & interpretation
Doug Millison
DMillison at ftmg.net
Tue Jun 12 12:49:14 CDT 2001
As the witnesses to the execution spoke through the day, their jarringly
different descriptions offered a lucid but unexplored commentary about the
power of the camera. The two network journalists chosen by lottery to watch,
Byron Pitts of CBS and Shepard Smith of the Fox News Channel, were careful
not to read anything into Mr. McVeigh's expression. Mr. Smith was especially
nuanced in reporting that Mr. McVeigh's skin had turned yellow and that he
had seemed to die painlessly; yet Mr. Smith was rare in remaining so
astutely aware that each witness would read the event differently. As Paul
Howell, whose daughter died in the bombing and who was also a witness, said,
"We didn't get anything from his face."
But many family members who watched on closed circuit television in Oklahoma
City saw something else. After seeing images from a stationary camera above
Mr. McVeigh that stared into his face, they said things like "We saw hatred"
and "It was like I was looking at the face of evil."
That lesson about the camera seemed willfully lost on the commentators, even
when they noticed it. On the Fox News Channel, John Gibson rhetorically
jumped up and down after a woman who had watched on closed circuit said it
was "a slap in the face" when Mr. McVeigh turned his head away. Mr. Gibson,
inflammatory as usual, didn't spend time wondering whether the people
watching thousands of miles away were imposing ideas on an image they could
not truly come close to.
http://www.nytimes.com/2001/06/12/national/12CRIT.html
More information about the Pynchon-l
mailing list