Israeli-American relations...
Dan Jizzenberry
pantychrist at hotmail.com
Wed Sep 12 22:11:30 CDT 2001
Some more reasons the U.S. supports Israel...
(1) Cold war fears helped initiate co-operation between Israel and the U.S.
Specifically, the American fear of allowing the Soviets to get their long
sought after warm water port. This would have, in turn, allowed the Soviets
to gain a foothold in the middle east, something that happened anyway due to
America's somewhat lopsided relationship with Israel and the surrounding
Arab states. Israel was also an important partner in America's fight
against both fundamentalists and hardcore nationalists such as Khomeini,
Nasir, etc.
(2) Jewish political pressure in the U.S. One of the reasons Truman
recognized Israel was because of their importance as a voting bloc. Check
out "Truman, the Jewish Vote, and the Creation of Israel" by John Snetsinger
(Stanford CA, 1974). Snetsinger points out that a less favorable approach to
Israel would have resulted in a Dewey victory (30,000 Jewish votes in 5 key
states was the difference between a Truman victory and a Truman defeat).
Convincing yet one-sided, because he doesn't mention any of the other
factors mentioned here. Snetsinger's analysis, in other words, is entirely
devoted to domestic political pressures and nothing else.
(3) One of the preconditions for the Rapture to come, according to
evangelical christians, is the return of Jews to their homeland (look up
Dispensationalism on the internet for a more thorough explanation). Truman
knew this and admitted that it was an important factor in his decision to
recognize Israel. One of the earliest supporters for the creation of a
Jewish state (before even Theodore Herzl) was the Methodist pastor William
Blackstone. Check out also Moshe Davis et al. "Christian Protagonists for
Jewish Restoration" (New York,1977). Contrary to popular opinion, most
evangelical sects are not anti-semitic and have been fervent supporters of a
Jewish homeland.
(4) Oil. Israel is one of the few middle eastern countries that is actually
a friend of the U.S. It is therefore strategically important w/r/t
protecting America's access to oil. This is the main reason America gets
involved in the middle east whenever conflict arises (e.g. Israel v.
Palestine; Iraq v. Iran; Iraq v. Kuwait; and pretty soon Iran v.
Afghanistan, mark my words). The fight against the Soviet Union,
fundamentalist regimes, and nationalist regimes are also tied up with oil
(see #1).
(5) They're the only democracy in the Middle-East (even though most
democracies insist on the separation of church and state). Their socialist
sensibilities offended some policy planners in the U.S. (and not a few
conservative congressman) but not enough to threaten their relationship with
America. Many politicians actually feared that Israel's socialist POV would
lead to an alliance with the Soviet Union. These fears were heightened when
the Soviets ostensibly agreed to the UN partition of Palesitine (they were
the first state to recognize Israel de jure). Nothing came of it though
because Russia (even Soviet Russia, though to a lesser extent) didn't treat
its Jews very well.
(6) And as "no fun" mentioned, humanitarian considerations. Specifically,
America's atrocious behavior before and during WWII w/r/t Jewish persecution
in Europe (e.g. Roosevelt's policies towards jewish refugees). Guilt over
the Holocaust cannot be downplayed in any discussion on the state of Israel.
_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com/intl.asp
More information about the Pynchon-l
mailing list