MDDM slavery WAS Re: Re[2]: Jefferson's Pillow

MalignD at aol.com MalignD at aol.com
Thu Jul 18 17:21:39 CDT 2002


<< Go ahead and disagree with the author of the article (without having read
the entire article), and bash the writers of the books reviewed in this
article (without having read them), if that's what you want to do.  >>

Well, you know, I admittted at the outset I was responding only to your 
excerpts of the review of a third person's book.

<<Go ahead and disagree with the author of the article (without having read
the entire article), and bash the writers of the books reviewed ... all 
you're doing now is airing your preconceived notions, with the addition of ad 
hominem attacks on people whose work you haven't read. >>

I'm not bashing the authors; I'm questioning some of the premises raised.  
And the ad hominem attacks are what exactly?  if you mean the professor who 
spoke favorably of the Klan, well too bad for him but, in any case, my 
characterization of him seems in keeping with the reviewer's, at least so far 
as you posted.

Stick to the facts, Scoop.



More information about the Pynchon-l mailing list