Pynchon and porno
robinlandseadel at comcast.net
robinlandseadel at comcast.net
Tue May 22 08:34:00 CDT 2007
Tore:
It's probably fair to say that P comes squarely
down on both sides of this question.
Here, Here!!!
T:
FWIW, though, I tend to believe that arousal is
the last thing that's on Pynchon's mind as he
writes his own pornographical scenes.
Conversly, if that's his intention, he failed. That Katje/Pudding scene is
one of life's great turn-offs.
T:
The scene between Katje and Pudding in GR, for
instance, is an exploration of power, of submission,
and of the reality of pain. . . .
. . . .and the brave boys, "our boys", getting gassed at Flanders, a subject
I'll have to deal with in a few months.
T:
The juicy triangle between Cyprian, Yashmeen, and Reef
in AtD is equally all about power. . . .
. . . .you forgot black magic, another of OBA's idées fixes. . . .
Of course, whatever label you choose to afix to these strenuous depictions,
ultimately they're still not arousing, at least in the usual sense. By way of
example: I was wondering, while considering the three-way scenes (In AtD,
like Noah's Ark, everything comes in matched pairs),"how does this
relate to Quaternions?"
T:
I'm not that sure of the scene between Slothrop and Bianca,
except that - again - its main purpose is not to arouse us.
One way of viewing the scene is as a subversion of the
corporate State's cooptation of the culture of childhood.
Of the rationale behind the children's resort Zwölfkinder we hear:
"In a corporate State, a place must be made for innocence,
and its many uses. In developing an official version of innocence,
the culture of childhood has proven invaluable." (GR, 419)
That was on my mind when I posted the link to:
http://hippiegoddess.com/sample/html/sshow001.html
It's all about turning desires into marketable commodities, like taking
Iggy Pop's "Lust For Life" and turning it into a jingle for some
"Supposedly Fun Thing I'll Never Do Again." What was once regarded
as liberating has been mutated into another one of "their" tools.
T:
In his essay "Reading Gravity's Rainbow After September Eleventh: An
Anecdotal Approach," David Rando has (convincingly, IMO) read the
sex scene between Slothrop and Bianca as "a means of resisting the
state's long history of appropriating the innocence of its children for
its prosecution of war." Once again, the main purpose of P's porno-
graphy is not to arouse, but - like Charlie Parker's music - "to gainsay
the Man's lullabies, to subvert the groggy wash of the endlessly, gut-
lessly overdubbed strings...."
(GR, 64).
What would you make of all the uses of the striptease and all the
mixed-metaphorical utilizations of the term "pornography" in
"The Crying of Lot 49"?
T:
There's pornography, and there's pornography, and my guess is
that Pynchon has little time for, or interest in, the kind of
pornography that's merely meant to let us approach "that Absolute
Comfort - the self-induced orgasm."
There's a genuine interest expressed in his Novels concerning the
subject. I'll agree he's on all sides of this issue, but none of us are certain
of any of the specifics of his private life, are we?
T:
That's certainly not the kind of pornography he practices in his novels,
but it is probably the kind of pornography practiced by Tristan
Taormino, and frankly I don't find it overly strange that he has
refrained from giving her his public support. Pynchon appropriates and
transforms some of pornography's codes for his own purposes, just as he
appropriates and transforms other codes of popular culture, but we
wouldn't expect him to publicly endorse any old porn flick, just as we
wouldn't expect him to publicly endorse Dan Brown's next novel, o-or
Die Hard 4.
As far as I can tell, the bulk of Annie Sprinkle's work would be classed in the
preterite catagory in which you're placing Tristan Taormino, but at the end of
the day I'd call the both of them Sex Educators. And I'd bet you anything that
OBA loves the Die-Hard franchise. That doesn't mean we should expect any pull
quotes from the man on the postmodern uses of "Let it Snow":
http://tinyurl.com/2hbkfy
More information about the Pynchon-l
mailing list