NP culinary question

[Heikki Raudaskoski]

When in Rome do as the Romans do... consequently, my friends and I tried
to immerse ourselves in the American burger culture when in NYC and DC.
(The "Five Guys" joint in DC was particularly adored by numerous friends
of mine - I never managed to visit it, though.)

I have a question concerning American English usage.

When you want every available topping on your burger, do you say
"a burger with all the toppings" [an option preferred by some friends] or
"a burger with everything on it" [an option preferred by me]?


Best,
Heikki