http://pynchonwiki WAS Re: ATD SPOILER p. 95

[Andrew Pollock]

pynchonoid,

I think that throughout this discussion you've consistently
misrepresented (misunderstood?) discussion as attack.  Your responses
to Jasper have read to me as overreaction bordering on bullying.
Similarly, your contention here that discussing the wiki on the p-list
is somehow misplaced is neither supported nor warranted.  Certainly
the pynchonwiki is of some moment to the pynchon community as we
embark on this new book, and while we *can* discuss it on site, it's
so appropriate a thing to discuss on the p-list that I'd be shocked
were such discussion confined to the wiki itself.

I've appreciated the contributions that I've seen you make to the
wiki, as well as your ability to incorporate modifications to how Tim
seems to want to see presentation occur there, but were I to form my
opinions of the workability of pynchonwiki from your over-strident
insistence here that raising questions amounts to "throwing rocks",
I'd likely never sign up.

Best,
Andrew


>Date: Wed, 29 Nov 2006 16:49:13 -0800 (PST)
>From: pynchonoid <pynchonoid at yahoo.com>
>Subject: http://pynchonwiki WAS Re: ATD SPOILER p. 95

>Again, http://pynchonwiki.com is the place for this
>discussion about how interpretations and opinions are
>to be handled -  go to the main page, click discussion
>and let your concerns be heard.  Nothing is gained by
>criticizing pynchonwiki here on pynchon-l, imo,  I'm
>here to invite people to take a look and participate
>if they're interested.